Analyzing an Argument Sample Essay.
PHL320T Week 5 Apply: Analyzing an Argument
2. Drag each concept to its corresponding definition.
3. Drag each concept to its corresponding definition.
4. Please answer the following questions.
“It was wrong for Alice to reveal Deborah’s secret when Deborah had asked her not to.” This is a nonmoral value judgment.
True
False
5. Drag the appropriate claim(s) to the value judgement category.
6. Post-Test
Please answer the following questions.
A person who says he’s against big government but doesn’t want to see any reductions or changes in Medicare
Top of Form
is being inconsistent and thus violating the principles of moral reasoning.
may appear inconsistent and thus has the burden of showing that he is not.
is violating both principles of moral reasoning.
has made an invalid deductive argument.
Bottom of Form
7. Post-Test
Please answer the following questions.
One problem regarding inconsistency in moral reasoning is that
no two cases should ever be seen as being the same.
the cases under consideration may not differ in any relevant way.
the argument may include an unstated general moral principle.
it can be difficult to evaluate whether two cases are the same or different.
8. Post-Test
Please answer the following questions.
“Doctors should help their terminally ill patients commit suicide by prescribing lethal doses of pain medication.” Which moral framework would most likely work to justify the action?
Top of Form
Utilitarianism
Deontology
Religious absolutism
Virtue ethics
Bottom of Form
9. Post-Test
Please answer the following questions.
Which of the following perspectives would most likely be used to justify a law requiring motorcyclists to wear helmets?
Top of Form
Legal paternalism
The harm principle
Legal moralism
The offense principle
10. Post-Test
Please answer the following questions.
“Six Flags has the scariest rides in the state.” This is an example of a
value principle.
moral principle.
value judgment.
moral value judgment.
11. Post-Test
Please answer the following questions.
“Six Flags has the scariest rides in the state.” This is an example of a
value principle.
moral principle.
value judgment.
moral value judgment.
Bottom of Form